lyme disease hearing, guidelines, and antibiotics use

Lyme Hearing Highlights a Broken System

Everything we think we know about Lyme needs to be rewritten, one doctor says.

Lyme Hearing Highlights a Broken System

Bad sign: Disagreements about how to handle Lyme disease put patients' health at risk.

RODALE NEWS, EMMAUS, PA— Borrelia burgdorferi is a sneak. And a smart one at that. Also known as Bb, it’s the organism that’s carried by certain ticks and causes Lyme disease, an infection that affects an estimated 200,000 people a year in the United States. Depending who you talk to, the Lyme bacterium causes a short-term infection that can be cured with a month’s worth of antibiotics or—as a growing number researchers, doctors, and patients say—it’s a serious pathogen that invades different organs, hides from detection by lab tests, and causes chronic pain and symptoms that lasts for months or years. Controversy over guidelines governing how doctors diagnose and treat the disease has been brewing for years, but yesterday the arguments were aired in public as 18 doctors, scientists, and patients testified at a hearing before a new Infectious Disease Society of America (IDSA) Lyme disease review panel in Washington, DC.

THE DETAILS: The hearing was a result of an antitrust settlement brought by the Connecticut attorney general to address alleged flaws (including financial conflicts of interest) regarding IDSA’s 2006 Lyme disease guidelines, which are recommended by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control. The nine-hour hearing featured prominent physicians who stand by the IDSA guidelines, those who treat more aggressively and prescribe longer and stronger doses of antibiotics (as recommended by the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society, ILADS), and independent Lyme disease researchers.

Here are some of the highlights from the hearing:

•Current guidelines suggest prescribing an immediate single dose of doxycycline if a person finds an attached tick on his or her body; however, one researcher pointed out, that dose won’t effectively block out infection, and it could lead to false-negative blood tests for Lyme. In other words, the practice could keep people who have the infection from being diagnosed correctly and given treatment.

•The blood tests of people who are chronically ill with Lyme disease could also come back negative because of past use of the antibiotic azithromycin. This is problematic because current guidelines rely on those blood tests to confirm Lyme if an infected person doesn’t develop the telltale bull’s-eye rash (which, by the way, fewer than half of Lyme patients get).

•Some Lyme patients report pain levels similar to that of people suffering from congestive heart failure or osteoarthritis.

•There are more than 100 different strains of the bacteria that causes Lyme disease, which could explain why some people with Lyme actually test negative on screening tests, or respond differently to treatment.

•Eugene Shapiro, MD, of IDSA and Yale University School of Medicine in Connecticut, reiterated IDSA’s viewpoint that people who remain sick after being treated with the standard month of antibiotics are not suffering from Lyme, but MUS—“medically unexplained symptoms.”

•Perhaps one of the most convincing presentations came from Allison Delong, MS, biostatistician for the Center for Statistical Sciences Program for Public Health at Brown University in Rhode Island. Delong explained major flaws in two studies heavily credited in creating the IDSA guidelines, and ones that are often used to discredit long-term antibiotic therapy. “She has the ability to lay out the math, and call out other studies as flawed and overrated,” says Daniel Cameron, MD, president of ILADS.

The new IDSA panel will take points from Thursday’s hearing into consideration, revisit peer-reviewed studies, and complete a report regarding guideline revisions by the end of the year.

WHAT IT MEANS:The problem that critics have with the current Lyme guidelines is that they are extremely restrictive, and consequently the testing leaves out many Lyme patients who don’t test positive. Doctors and specialists all across the country adhere to the guidelines; if they don’t, in all but three states (Rhode Island, New York, and Connecticut), they risk losing their licenses. But as the testimonies were laid out by people on different sides of the issue Thursday, it became apparent that the current two-tiered testing system, relying on ELISA and Western Blot blood tests, are not nearly accurate enough. In fact, one presenter, Steven Phillips, MD, former president of ILADS, says current screening tests have a sensitivity between 45 to 55 percent. That leaves out a lot of people who are having trouble receiving treatment because they don’t test positive. And health insurance companies don’t have to pay for treatment if a patient doesn’t test positive. “Commercial testing for Lyme disease is broken. It needs to be fixed. This panel needs to at least recognize that and revise the guidelines,” says Dr. Phillips.

Lyme disease is complex, but here are some basics to be ware of:

We don’t know it all. One of the memorable moments of the long hearing occurred when Ken Liegner, MD, a member of ILADS, said quite plainly, “A general reassessment of everything that is believed to be true about Lyme disease is necessary.” He added, “We have to come to terms. This is a formidable pathogen, there’s a still a lot we don’t understand.” Resolving many of the issues will require more scientific research and less rancor between camps. As science writer Pam Weintraub points out in her award-winning book Cure Unknown: Inside the Lyme Epidemic, the fight over Lyme has become politicized and ugly. “What we really need is more research. If independent people can make this clear, whether the guidelines are changed or not, maybe that’s progress.”

Antibiotics are an important option. One of the biggest controversies in Lyme treatment is the use of antibiotics, particularly long-term use. While this type of treatment can sometimes pose serious side effects, studies have also shown it helps those suffering from chronic Lyme, especially in the fatigue department. If you’re diagnosed with Lyme disease and still don’t feel better after initial treatment, consider seeking a second opinion from a doctor willing to treat Lyme more aggressively. As one presenter put it on Thursday, long-term antibiotic use may not be the answer, but it’s the best thing we’ve got right now.

Prevention is paramount. Of course, the best tactic is to avoid the disease. That may become harder and harder to do as tick populations explode, thanks to warmer winters, large deer populations, and fragmented forests. When you’re outside in wooded areas, wear a hat and light-colored clothing, and tuck your pants into your socks. When you get back, do a vigorous tick check, paying extra attention to darker, moist areas like your groin and armpits, and under your bra line. If you find a tick that’s attached, or even engorged, remove it by using tweezers to pull it off (grasp close to the skin, pull slowly and firmly, don’t twist). Toss the tick in some alcohol and take it with you to your doctor’s office. If you ever find a bull’s-eye-shaped rash, you have Lyme. Go to the doctor right away for treatment. When the disease is caught early, it’s more treatable.

Get tested twice. If you think, or know, you were recently bitten by a tick, and your first ELISA test comes back negative, schedule another one for a few weeks later. Barbara Johnson, PhD, of the CDC, said at the hearing that it is sometimes necessary to take a second sample a few weeks after the first to get an accurate reading.

Know where to turn. If you are diagnosed with Lyme, or suspect you have it (and have ruled other health ailments out), join a Lyme support group to find doctors and tips on dealing with the disease—and how to beat it! Start with


Published on: July 30, 2009

More from our Authors

This breakthrough information links the little-known connection between diabetes, fatigue, heart disease, weight gain, high blood pressure, and more! Click here to learn more.

This can get way better as I

This can get way better as I believe man. Theses | Assignments | Courseworks | Dissertations | Custom essay

Don't rely on finding a tick

Don't rely on finding a tick attached to your body to gauge your Lyme disease risk: Many people don’t recall being bitten at all, while others notice migrating rashes or red or black-and-blue splotches shortly after being bitten. Other early Lyme symptoms sometimes pop up a few days to a month after infection and include fatigue, fever, and chills. If the disease becomes more established in your body, it could cause cardiac and neurological problems.
java programmer

Lyme vaccine

Can't ever forsee a LYME VACCINE.

Lymerix was an absolute failure leaving
many in terrible health.

Can't make a Lyme vaccine due to all the hundreds or thousands of strains constantly evolving and picking up DNA interacting in new ways. A vaccine can't be done and is impossible at this point in time.

This spirochete is so adaptable and hides so easily to evade the immune system and the Ridiculous Commercial Lyme test that "We all should be humbled by it"

Vaccinate against something so clever we needed to be humbled by it? NOT GOING TO HAPPEN.

Silly Lyme, FM, CFS Treaments-Fail Too Often

Lyme alone in PA is a silly joke. Deer ticks carry a flood of Babesia and Bartonella and other infections our top state labs cannot even test for. Our top medical centers have NO ONE publishing top books on these infections--they just send you out with a treatment meet to fit 10 y/o's, 30 y/o's and 50 y/o's--everyone is the same and has only Lyme.

If you do not use a trash lab with triviual inventment and huge frekishly high cut off positive numbers on finds much of FM and Crippling fatigue is Babesia, Lyme or Bartonella that is hardly a mere cold and passes away.

If any one in PA has read even a mere 1500 articles on each of these infections, I would be stunned.


Is this ALL we have to say. This article is NOTHING new. Why bother chunking up email boxes with this. Funny I had Hyson Infuse as my code below.

Got to get this right!

Between living in a Lyme Tick area, knowing 2 people who suffer from chronic Lyme Disease, and wondering if the Lyme vaccine we received years ago still is working (It's since been pulled off the market)....
I know the doctors and scientists have to get this right. The problem will only get worse as more and more people contract the disease and are given incorrect care

Start Your Wellness Journey!
Sign up for updates on Rodale Wellness and get your FREE wellness journal to help you find your path to vibrant health. Click here to start your unique journey!

Free Newsletter
Sign up for our FREE newsletters to stay up to date on all of our wellness news.

  The Daily Fix
Useful news and practical tips to help you live a healthy life on a healthier planet.

  Wellness in Action
Find your path to vibrant health, and get your free wellness journal as our thanks!

You may unsubscribe at any time.

Your Privacy Rights. About Us.